Show simple item record

dc.contributor.authorMartin, Benjamin Joseph Lewis
dc.date.accessioned2019-06-26T13:17:32Z
dc.date.available2019-06-26T13:17:32Z
dc.date.issued2019
dc.PublishedMartin BJL. Searching for Deep Disagreement in Logic: The Case of Dialetheism. Topoi. 2019eng
dc.identifier.issn0167-7411
dc.identifier.issn1572-8749
dc.identifier.urihttps://hdl.handle.net/1956/20461
dc.description.abstractAccording to Fogelin’s account of deep disagreements, disputes caused by a clash in framework propositions are necessarily rationally irresolvable. Fogelin’s thesis is a claim about real-life, and not purely hypothetical, arguments: there are such disagreements, and they are incapable of rational resolution. Surprisingly then, few attempts have been made to find such disputes in order to test Fogelin’s thesis. This paper aims to rectify that failure. Firstly, it clarifies Fogelin’s concept of deep disagreement and shows there are several different breeds of such disagreements. Thus, to fully assess Fogelin’s thesis, it will be necessary to seek out cases of each breed to evaluate their rational irresolvability. Secondly, it begins this task by looking at a significant debate within the logical literature over the truth of contradictions. We demonstrate that, while the debate exemplifies a breed of deep disagreement, the parties involved can supply one another with rationally compelling reasons.en_US
dc.language.isoengeng
dc.publisherSpringereng
dc.subjectDeep disagreementseng
dc.subjectFogelineng
dc.subjectFramework propositionseng
dc.subjectLogical disputeseng
dc.subjectDialetheismeng
dc.subjectContradictionseng
dc.titleSearching for Deep Disagreement in Logic: The Case of Dialetheismeng
dc.typePeer reviewed
dc.typeJournal article
dc.date.updated2019-03-02T16:41:34Z
dc.description.versionacceptedVersion
dc.rights.holderCopyright Springer Nature B.V. 2019eng
dc.identifier.doihttps://doi.org/10.1007/s11245-019-09639-4
dc.identifier.cristin1681912
dc.source.journalTopoi


Files in this item

Thumbnail

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record