Show simple item record

dc.contributor.authorBeller, Sieghard
dc.contributor.authorBender, Andrea
dc.description.abstractIn determining the prime cause of a physical event, people often weight one of two entities in a symmetric physical relation as more important for bringing about the causal effect than the other. In a broad survey (Bender and Beller, 2011), we documented such weighting effects for different kinds of physical events and found that their direction and strength depended on a variety of factors. Here, we focus on one of those: adding a contrast situation that—while being formally irrelevant—foregrounds one of the factors and thus frames the task in a specific way. In two experiments, we generalize and validate our previous findings by using different stimulus material (in Experiment 1), by applying a different response format to elicit causal assignments, an analogue rating scale instead of a forced-choice decision (in Experiment 2), and by eliciting explanations for the physical events in question (in both experiments). The results generally confirm the contrast effects for both response formats; however, the effects were more pronounced with the force-choice format than with the rating format. People tended to refer to the given contrast in their explanations, which validates our manipulation. Finally, people’s causal assignments are reflected in the type of explanation given in that contrast and property explanations were associated with biased causal assignments, whereas relational explanations were associated with unbiased assignments. In the discussion, we pick up the normative questions of whether or not these contrast effects constitute a bias in causal reasoning.en_US
dc.rightsAttribution CC BYeng
dc.subjectcausal cognitioneng
dc.subjectphysical domaineng
dc.subjectcausal judgmentseng
dc.subjectframing effecteng
dc.subjectcontrast effecteng
dc.subjectcontent effecteng
dc.titleHow contrast situations affect the assignment of causality in symmetric physical settingseng
dc.typePeer reviewed
dc.typeJournal article
dc.rights.holderCopyright 2015 The Authorseng
dc.source.journalFrontiers in Psychology

Files in this item


This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record

Attribution CC BY
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Attribution CC BY